Discord & Rhyme: An Album Podcast

Discord and Rhyme is a podcast where we discuss the albums we love, song by song.

041: Radiohead - Hail to the Thief (2003)

“I kind of don’t [think it works]. In a way that’s the criticism I would have of it. It didn’t really have its own direction. It was almost like a homogeny of previous work. Maybe that’s its strength?”

—Nigel Godrich

The 2003 Radiohead album Hail to the Thief was widely praised as a great album upon its initial release, but starting a few years later it became a consistent target of criticism from the band and fans alike. In this episode, John leads a discussion with Will, Mike, and Phil in which they try to make the case that this album, in which Radiohead largely consolidates the different approaches of its post-Bends work into something new and yet still something recognizably Radiohead, deserves a significantly better reputation than as “the Radiohead album with too many songs.” Come for the serious discussion of Radiohead’s take on the Iraq War and society’s failings, stay for the recurring sex jokes and Homestar Runner references.

Miscellany

  • John made a reference during his personal history to not listening to an early version of Hail to the Thief from before the album’s release. In late March 2003, an unfinished (without proper mixing and editing) version of the album leaked without the band’s consent, and John very deliberately went out of his way to not hear anything from this early version.

  • John made a slight mistake in reference to the statistical analysis regarding sadness in Radiohead songs (linked below): according to the study, “We Suck Young Blood” is tied with “True Love Waits” as the saddest song, but only before lyrics are accounted for. After lyrics are accounted for it falls out of the top ten (“True Love Waits” remains the champion)

  • Despite Mike’s claims to the contrary, there are only two guitars on “There There.” And he should know this, because he’s seen them perform it live twice. We’ll chalk it up to Radiohead’s remarkable ability to make two guitars sound like three, because it’s impossible that Mike wouldn’t know what he’s talking about.

  • During the “Sit Down, Stand Up” discussion two references were made to backwards masking outside the context of that song. The first refers to an instance of backwards masking at the beginning of the song “Empty Spaces” off the Pink Floyd album The Wall. The second (“Satan eats cheez whiz”) references a parody of backwards masking found in the Weird Al Yankovic song “Nature Trail to Hell.”

  • For our listeners who fall outside of the X-ennial window, the mention of “Strong Mad” in the “Myxomatosis” discussion refers to a character from the Homestar Runner website, a Flash-based mainstay of the internet from around the time this album was released. This was edited out of the episode, but after Mike responded to the mention with “Intruder Alert!!” John became paralyzed with laughter and needed a minute before he could continue.

  • Just before we recorded this, Radiohead’s official website underwent a major revamp, and as part of this they made available an incredible amount of rare footage and difficult-to-find material. It’s linked below and it’s absolutely worth visiting if you are interested in the band. 

Other links 

Discord & Rhyme Roll Call 

  • John McFerrin (host)

  • Phil Maddox (moderator)

  • Mike DeFabio

  • Chris Willie Williams

  • Rich Bunnell (guest appearance)

  • Amanda Rodgers (guest appearance) 

Hail to the Thief tracklist 

  1. 2 + 2 = 5

  2. Sit Down, Stand Up

  3. Sail to the Moon

  4. Backdrifts

  5. Go to Sleep

  6. Where I End and You Begin

  7. We Suck Young Blood

  8. The Gloaming

  9. There There

  10. I Will

  11. A Punchup at a Wedding

  12. Myxomatosis

  13. Scatterbrain

  14. A Wolf at the Door 

Other clips used 

Radiohead:

  • I Get Louder

  • Fitter Happier

  • The National Anthem (from I Might Be Wrong)

  • Airbag

  • Paranoid Android

  • Cuttooth

  • Creep

  • Street Spirit (Fade Out)

  • No Surprises

  • Everything in Its Right Place

  • Pyramid Song

  • Subterranean Homesick Alien

  • Pulk/Pull Revolving Doors

  • 33.3 Recurring

  • The Gloaming (Live from the Basement)

  • The Gloaming (DJ Shadow Remix)

  • Like Spinning Plates

  • I Will (Los Angeles Version) 

Others:

  • Talking Heads - Radio Head

  • Joan Baez - All the Pretty Little Horses

  • Simon Gale and His Music - Flying Over San Jose

  • The Mothers of Invention - Who Are the Brain Police?

  • Thee Silver Mt. Zion Memorial Orchestra - God Bless Our Dead Marines

  • Can - Mushroom

  • Tim Curry - I Will

  • Procol Harum - Cerdes (Outside the Gates of)

  • T. Rex - Left Hand Luke & the Beggar Boys

Songs we mentioned but didn’t clip 

Radiohead:

  • Idioteque

  • Fake Plastic Trees

  • Electioneering

  • My Iron Lung

  • Planet Telex

  • Just

  • High and Dry

  • True Love Waits

  • The Tourist

  • Optimistic

  • You and Whose Army

  • Knives Out

  • Climbing Up the Walls

  • Paperbag Writer 

Others:

  • Peter Gabriel - Street Spirit (Fade Out)

  • The Kinks - 20th Century Man

  • Steely Dan - Two Against Nature

  • Bob Dylan - The Times They Are a-Changin’

  • The Clash - Ivan Meets G.I. Joe

  • The Rolling Stones - Gimme Shelter

  • Pink Floyd - Empty Spaces

  • “Weird Al” Yankovic - Nature Trail to Hell

  • Sparks - Missionary Position

  • U2 - The Fly

  • Procol Harum - The Thin End of the Wedge

  • The Beatles - I Will

  • A Perfect Circle - Disillusioned

  • Genesis - That’s All

  • Fear - New York’s Alright If You Like Saxophones

  • Fear - Let’s Have a War

  • Jeff Beck - Scatterbrain

  • Jethro Tull - Aqualung

  • R.E.M. - Belong

  • The Grateful Dead - Dire Wolf

  • Atoms for Peace - Amok

Hail to the Thief personnel 

  • Thom Yorke – voice, words, guitar, piano, laptop

  • Jonny Greenwood – guitar, analogue systems, ondes Martenot, laptop, toy piano, glockenspiel

  • Colin Greenwood – bass, string synth, sampler

  • Ed O'Brien – guitar, effects, voice

  • Philip Selway – drums, percussion

  • Nigel Godrich – recording, editing, operation, mixing

  • Darrell Thorp – engineering, backing up, cataloguing

  • Plank – instrument maintenance and rebuilding

  • Graeme Stewart – tape loops on "The Gloaming", engineering of preliminary sessions

  • Stanley Donwood – painting, packaging

Credits 

“Discord & Rhyme (theme),” composed by the Other Leading Brand, contains elements of:

  • Duran Duran - Hungry Like the Wolf

  • Amon Düül II - Dehypnotized Toothpaste

  • The Dukes of Stratosphear - What in the World?? ...

  • Faith No More - Midlife Crisis

  • Herbie Hancock - Hornets

  • Kraftwerk - Autobahn

  • Talking Heads - Seen and Not Seen

  • Radiohead - Backdrifts (this episode only)

You can buy or stream Hail to the Thief and other albums by Radiohead at the usual suspects such as Spotify, Apple Music, YouTube, and Amazon [affiliate link]. Follow Discord & Rhyme on Twitter @DiscordPod for news, updates, and other random stuff. Editing is by Rich Bunnell, and special thanks to our own Mike DeFabio, the Other Leading Brand, for production. See you next album, and be ever wonderful.

This website and all episodes' discussion/commentary © 2018—2024 Discord & Rhyme. Excerpts from recordings appearing in episodes are included for purposes of review only, and all rights to such material remain property of their copyright holders. Please note that we make a good-faith effort to ensure all information included in these episodes is accurate, but if we get something wrong, let us know at discordpod@gmail.com and we will print a correction in the show notes. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Website design by Amanda Rodgers. Thank you for visiting, and keep as cool as you can.

Powered by Squarespace